From Airbnb to Co-Living: Why Toronto Investors Are Switching

From Airbnb to Co-Living: Why Toronto Investors Are Switching

By Austine Mayodi · · 7 min read

For a while, Airbnb seemed like a straightforward way to make money from an investment property. But for many property owners, the reality has become more complicated. Changing city regulations and the constant work of managing guest turnover can quickly make short-term rentals less appealing. That’s why some investors are starting to look for an Airbnb alternative for their investment property.

One Toronto investor who approached us for help managing her property explained that the numbers initially looked promising, but the time and effort involved in running an Airbnb soon became a concern. It’s a situation many property owners are now facing, and it’s raising a bigger question: is there a better way to earn from an investment property? For some, coliving property management offers a different model, with longer stays and less day-to-day turnover.

Toronto Airbnb Rules: What Investment Property Owners Need to Know

Before you look for an Airbnb alternative for your investment property, it’s worth understanding the rule that changed things in Toronto. The City of Toronto only allows short-term rentals in an operator’s principal residence. In simple terms, this is the home where you actually live. So, if you own a separate investment property that you don’t live in, you generally can’t register it as a short-term rental.

For many Toronto investors, this creates a real challenge. If you bought a property specifically to earn income from Airbnb but don’t live there, you may no longer be able to operate it as a short-term rental. And hiring a property manager for Airbnb won’t solve the problem if the property doesn’t meet the city’s requirements.

The income potential hasn’t disappeared. But the model you planned to use may no longer be an option. So, what other ways can you earn from your investment property?

Exploring Coliving as an Airbnb Alternative

If you’re considering an Airbnb alternative for your investment property, you may be wondering how coliving compares with hiring an Airbnb property manager.

One investor we spoke with had a short-term booking that brought in around $3,800 a month. While the income looked promising, she wanted to explore whether a different management model could offer a more manageable way to earn from her property. A traditional Airbnb property manager focuses on short-term bookings. They handle guest communication, check-ins, cleaning, and pricing between stays. Coliving property management works differently. Instead of managing nightly bookings, the team finds and screens residents who rent individual rooms for several months at a time.

That means fewer turnovers and more predictable monthly rental income. You still earn from your property, but you don’t have to manage the constant demands that come with short-term guests.

Switching from Airbnb to Coliving Property Management

Switching from Airbnb to coliving property management on a Toronto property follows a clear process. If you’re considering an Airbnb alternative for your investment property, here’s what you can expect to change.

  • The rental agreement: Instead of short-term booking arrangements, residents sign a licence to occupy. This sets out the terms of their stay and the responsibilities involved.
  • Resident screening: Rather than reviewing guests for short visits, the management team screens prospective residents. This can include identity verification, background checks, and lifestyle compatibility matching.
  • Furnishing and setup: You’ll prepare the property for people staying for several months, not a few nights. The focus shifts to creating comfortable, practical shared spaces that residents can use every day.
  • Rental income: Instead of relying on nightly rates and changing occupancy, you earn a fixed monthly amount from each occupied room. This gives you a clearer picture of the income your property can generate.

The transition usually takes a few weeks, depending on the property’s condition and the setup required. Unlike hiring a traditional property manager for Airbnb, you’re preparing the property for a different rental model altogether.

Can Coliving Generate More Rental Income?

If you’re weighing an Airbnb alternative for your investment property, income will likely be one of your biggest considerations. And it’s worth looking beyond what you could earn in a single month.

Airbnb can bring in more during peak travel periods. However, your annual returns also depend on occupancy, cleaning costs, guest turnover, and seasonal demand. Even with a good Airbnb property manager, these factors can affect how much you keep.

Coliving takes a different approach. You earn monthly rent from individual rooms, which can make income more predictable throughout the year. The room-by-room model can also generate more than renting the entire property to one tenant.

That doesn’t mean coliving will always outperform Airbnb. The results depend on your property’s location, room layout, pricing, and operating costs. The better comparison is what each model could earn over a full year, not just during a busy season.

What to Expect from a Coliving Property Manager

If you’re considering an Airbnb alternative for your investment property, you may wonder how much control you’ll keep. With Sparrow, the team handles property setup, listings, resident screening, rent collection, licence-to-occupy administration, daily coordination, and room cleaning. You still approve the management approach, handle major maintenance, and make key ownership decisions.

You should also understand the legal arrangement. Coliving may use a licence to occupy rather than a standard tenancy agreement or short-term rental booking. The right arrangement depends on how the property operates, so it’s worth having a lawyer review the agreement before switching.

A property manager for Airbnb handles guest bookings and turnover. Coliving management covers a different set of responsibilities, but knowing who handles what helps you make an informed decision.

Is Coliving the Right Airbnb Alternative for Your Investment Property?

If your Toronto investment property no longer qualifies for short-term rentals, or managing Airbnb guests has become too much work, it may be time to consider another option.

Coliving property management offers a different way to earn from your property. You can rent individual rooms to longer-term residents without managing nightly bookings and constant guest turnover yourself. An Airbnb alternative for your investment property doesn’t have to mean giving up rental income. It means choosing a model that better fits your property, goals, and the time you’re willing to commit.

Want to find out what your property could earn through coliving? Book a call with our team to explore your unit’s earning potential.


FAQs

What is coliving property management?

Coliving property management involves renting individual rooms to residents who share common spaces. A management team handles listings, resident screening, rent collection, and day-to-day coordination.

Can I still run Airbnb on an investment property in Toronto?

Generally, no, if the property isn’t your principal residence. Toronto requires short-term rental operators to register their principal residence before offering short-term stays.

How is coliving property management different from an Airbnb property manager?

An Airbnb property manager handles short-term guest bookings, check-ins, cleaning, and turnover. Coliving property management like Sparrow focuses on placing longer-term residents in individual rooms and managing their stays.

Is coliving more profitable than Airbnb for an investment property?

It depends on your property’s location, layout, rental demand, and operating costs. Airbnb may earn more during peak seasons, while coliving can offer more consistent monthly income. Compare annual returns before choosing a model.

What do I need to change to switch from Airbnb to coliving?

You’ll need to prepare the rooms for longer stays, arrange suitable rental agreements, and set up resident screening and management. Working with a coliving property management team can help you handle the transition.


Leave a Comment